Hamilton
Secondary College's Maths coordinator, Peter Searle, expects
a smooth transition: "I'm not expecting
this year's exam to be very different to the past. However,
this year has helped us get organised with arrangements for
hiring, buying and short-term loans," he said.
Mr Searle
said the main advantage this year would be "a
check or support for students doing the questions. By entering
the function and drawing the graph the students can predict
answers they are aiming at algebraically".
As for the
future use of personal computers in exams, Mr Searle said
many issues would need to be resolved, ruling it out at
Hamilton "for some time".
Hamilton's Year 12 Maths
teacher Kathy Minge says most students have been using
graphics calculators for two years.
"They allow students to concentrate on applications
and understandings - rather than spending lots of time doing
repetitive calculations. In an exam they will be useful to
check answers," she said.
However,
some, she believes, are less comfortable with the technology, "...particularly
adults who are less familiar with the calculators than
students who have been using them for four or five
years."
Ms
Minge said despite the difficulties that come with
adapting to change, similar concerns have been dealt
with in the past.
"Just as the move from log books to scientific calculators
proved successful, the move to graphic calculators or PCs will
work," she said.
The top adult student in her Year
12 class this year, Floyd Elmes, 66, has reservations
about the need for change.
"Frankly I find the effort of learning and remembering
how to use them not worth the trouble," he said. "They're
useful for graphing a complex function. Apart from that, a
good scientific calculator is sufficient." (SSABSA
conditions for using calculators allow students to take
2 pages of handwritten notes into the exam room, as memory-joggers
for the more complex keystrokes.)
Michael
Lyas, 17, says graphics calculators "can
be helpful and get through some problems quicker. They're
good to visualise graphs so you understand what's going
on. But you still have to know the maths. If you don't
know what you are doing you can still mess up."
But Michael
has concerns about future generations using personal computers
in exams, which he believes could be an "unreliable
way" to assess knowledge. He believes "people who
are good with computers could use them to cheat".
SSABSA
Chief Executive Dr Jan Keightley says concerns raised
about using computers during exams will be addressed
through even more thorough consultation with all parties.
"Already, computers are used in school-assessed work.
Half of last year's results involved no restriction on the
use of computers," she says. "In many subjects
where writing is involved, word-processing is the norm,
and Geographic Information Systems are used in Geography.
"SSABSA
must provide curriculum that balances the inevitable
demand for computer competency with the interests of
the student." |